Normally, I am not getting review units. This is due to the fact that I am only hosting this small weblog, along some conference talks - and most companies would probably be better off to send their units along someone with a reach of Linus Tech Tips, or similar.
On the other hand - when I get the possibility to do a review, it can be a bit worrisome for the companies as well, as I am a very honest person. I have been working in tech for some time now and had the honor to build stuff which went to space - and came back to tell the tale. I know what I want in a unit - and what could be a problem.
With this out of the way, I was one lucky winner of the Advantech Edge AI Challenge 2022 and got an AIR-020X-S9A1 unit at no charge to be able to realize my labSentinel 2 project. By doing this project I learned a bit about the box and thought it would not be a bad idea to share my ideas with the readers of my blog - and also Advantech, so that they can improve upon their product. This review is not paid for, reflects my own thoughts and I got the mentioned unit for my project - the review was not a part of that deal. With that out of the way, lets get started.
The hardware
The AIR-020X comes very well packaged - having its own foam jacket which will save it from all but the most horrible abuse from postal services. Not that it would matter: The roughly 14 cm x 12 cm x 4,5 cm compact unit weighs in at nearly 850 gr and is built sturdy and robust - like a tank:
The most obvious part of the unit is its heatsink, which it does put to good use - but more on that topic later. Along with the computer itself comes a chinese printed starting guide and a short USB A to Micro B cable, which will be needed to factory reset and reflash the unit.
All in all, the AIR-020X is an impressive unit, including an Nvidia Jetson Xavier NX module with 8 GB RAM, 16 GB onboard eMMC, 128 GB M.2 Flash, 2x RS232/422/485, 1x CANbus, 1xDIO ("GPIO"), 2x 1 Gbit ethernet, 1x Fullsize mPCIe with nano SIM holder, 1x 4k HDMI Output, 2x USB 3.0 Type A, 1x USB Type C. The unit is powered by a 12-24 V DC power supply, which is an optional accessory.
Being an industrial unit, it uses an industrial type connector for power, which is an HT5.08 2 pole type:
As this connector is also not part of the base package and the USB C connector does not accept power delivery (and neither works in Display Port Mode) - it becomes a bit harder to power up the unit after receiving it. Finding a usable power supply within the sizable voltage range of 12 - 24 V (e.g. from an old Laptop) is fairly easy, but without the connector - it becomes a dead end until the next delivery is there. It would be useful to at least include one connector with the base unit. The usb cable is a nice addition, but could be left out (even though its very high quality) - along with the chinese manual. This could be replaced with a small card with direct links to the english and chinese PDF versions of the manual.
Opening up the unit reveals the internals - but not without a fight:
The used screws are perfectly fixed to the structure by using blue loctite - a touch I cannot recommend enough for the vibration resistance of the overall unit - but the screws themselves are made from extremely soft metal, so that - using the correct screwdriver - I stripped nearly all screws and had really issues removing all of them. Somehow this problem seems to exist for all the external black screws, the internal silver ones were of a lot higher quality. In my case I fixed the issue by replacing the screws with new ones and never had an issue anymore with them.
The internal structure is very well laid out, raising the M.2 drive onto a pole to keep it a bit further from the heat source / Xavier NX module which is just sitting on the other side of the PCB and directly sandwiches with the big heatsink.
Very welcome are also the addition of the two Raspberry Pi Style Camera connectors, although they are a bit hidden by the serial console cables. I understand that the unit should be as closed as possible for the use in factories, but I would have loved to see two small slits (possibly even with some IP/EMC gaskets to allow for protective shielding of those entry points) so that cameras on the outside of the case can be easily attached.
The mPCIe slot gives the system an additional expansion slot for e.G. UMTS or LoRaWAN modules and also the internal CR2032 cell for the RTC is a small but valuable detail.
The AIR-020X has some mounting points available on both system sides for additional wall mounting rails. Looking at the mounting points and the obvious use of the AIR-020 series in lab and factory settings, the inclusion of a DIN rail mount as available accessory could prove very useful to directly mount this small computer into an electrical cabinet.
The software
Booting up the system greats one with a very familiar picture: Ubuntu 18.04 is running on the machine in form of a tailored version of Nvidia Jetpack. This version by Advantech is only using the eMMC of the Xavier NX module to start the bootloader, but the actual data is kept on the M.2. This is a great idea for the longevity of the eMMC on the (currently hard to find) Xavier NX module - but comes with the drawback of additional needed customization other than "only" the PCB, included hardware, drivers and other changes made by Advantech in comparision to an Nvidia Developerboard for the same module.
This is a problem I also learned the hard way: I realized that the board was delivered with L4T 32.5.2 - not the current 32.7.x (JetPack 4.6.1) - so I updated this by hand. Just to have the board bootloop. This was the moment I took a closer look to the online presence of Advantech and the manual - just to learn that the recovery process was neither described, nor was the download of the image available. I got the needed recovery file as well as the documentation (which also included vital information on how to use the DIO (GPIO), RS422 and CANbus interface) and as able to restore the board to working order. Obviously there were multiple problems with this: First, the online available manual should contain all needed information regardings settings, ports, recovery, etc - secondly, the current (and maybe even last) images also need to be available online on their website - with checksums to be able to deploy these images safetly.
I also voiced my concerns regarding the high impact security issues / CVEs found in 32.5.2 - which would make the use of AIR-020 series an absolute liability in a production environment. I am glad to report that Advantech reacted to these concerns with providing a beta version of a new JetPack 4.6.1 Image. A short time afterwards, Advantech did add some information to their wiki:
- Main Page (the Release Note leads to Downloads)
- Build instructions for the BSPs
- Downloads
On the download page you can find the AIR020A2AIM20UIV00004 entry for the Jetson NX JetPack 4.6.1 from 2022-07-20. This links to a Dropbox folder containing a the latest image (AIR020A2AIM20UIV00004_194.tar.gz / 2022-09-16).
With this latest image I was able to upgrade the AIR-020X to JetPack 4.6.1 and even do and apt upgrade to upgrade to L4T 32.7.2, at the time the latest L4T. However, this did not go as planed: After doing the upgrade and rebooting the device, it got caught in a bootloop. This bootloop kept on repeating for about 10 minutes until the device mysteriously started then working and came back on without issues. Obviously this would not be a graceful upgrade and did instill some concerns why this was a reproducible issue.
I am glad to report that Advantech has provided the latest image - which will eliminate several security issues. However, the changes needed in the manual as well as the provision of the recovery images (now via Dropbox?) and the secure provision of security updates to the unit remain. Maybe Advantech would think about starting to use balena.io to handle these issues?
Verdict
The Advantech AIR-020X is an extremely capable unit in a small form factor, sturdy built and highly reliable. Even with the latest JetPack 4.6.1 and abuse of the formerly not available 20 Watt mode I could not get this unit to heat up too much in my testing with labSentinel 2. There is still enough headroom available to use it in any kind of environment, which makes it a perfect choice for labs and factories - if Advantech can tackle the presented issues. Especially the ones regarding timely and secure availability of security patches and software updates. This also means availability of these images, fast adaption after release of official Nvidia updates and all needed documentation in one manual for public download. With these exceptions and some small kinks, Advantech is so close to building the perfect unit for their envisioned use case. I really hope they can close that last (security/software/manual) gap to an otherwise nearly perfect hardware - and with that create an recommendable product.
Edit: balenaOS
I got balenaOS working on the device - see here.
Did you try balenaOS on it?
Well, I was preparing something - here you go 😉